Perfect Pies for the Holidays

Which pies to look for this season, from pecan to pear pumpkin to pizza.

(page 2 of 5)

Pecan Pie (Sticking to Tradition) 

$14 Galloway’s Country Kitchen, Scarsdale

This Scarsdale pastry shop gives Southern bakers a run for their money with a Thanksgiving favorite—pecan pie. Galloway’s heaps mounds of pecans in sticky goodness for a pie that’s got so many people hooked, it has a cult-like following. Heads up—the bakery is open only Friday through Sunday and is cash-only, so make sure to plan accordingly. If you manage to score a pie, sweeten your serving with a scoop of maple ice cream.

Secure your slice: One week in advance

69 Harney Rd (914) 725-4074


Chocolate Salted Caramel Pie (At the Trendsetter’s Table) 

$18-$24 Martine’s Fine Bake Shoppe, Tuckahoe and Scarsdale

A bakery known for it’s wide range of unique treats, Martine’s steps it up when it comes to its holiday offerings. A special ingredient always inspires more than a few options, and this year the hot flavor—chocolate salted caramel—is creamy with a savory twist. Serve up a slice slightly chilled with a dollop of whipped cream.

Secure your slice: Three days in advance

10 Fisher Ave, Tuckahoe (914) 346-8650; 48 E Parkway, Scarsdale (914) 722-4949




What To Read Next

Edit Module