Advertisement
Bookmark and Share Email this page Email Print this page Print

Thanksgiving, The Civil War, And Cranberry Sauce

(Or, why that goo shows up every year).

Next to turkey and stuffing, no food is more linked to Thanksgiving than cranberry sauce; you’d think that buckle-shoed Pilgrims were slipping tubes of jellied Ocean Spray onto the original Plymouth table.

In fact, the American Thanksgiving tradition of cranberry sauce started when Civil War Union General Ulysses S. Grant served the condiment to his troops during the Siege of Petersburg. This bitter, nine-month stalemate also marked the beginnings of trench warfare, with both forces stubbornly embedded, sniping from mud holes over a long, Virginia winter. The Confederate Army finally yielded in 1865, ceding the Confederate capital, Richmond, Virginia, to the Union Army. We commemorate Grant’s linchpin Civil War victory every year by consuming cranberry sauce.

And while we’d like to think that those Pilgrims were eating bronzed Butterball turkeys, there are no documents remaining from 1621 that describe the actual menu of the original feast. In fact, we don’t even know the exact autumn month in which it occurred—the original Thanksgiving meal might have been eaten in September or October (though we know it took three days to eat). Again, our modern Thanksgiving meal has Civil War-era origins: in 1863, President Abraham Lincoln proclaimed that Thanksgiving would be celebrated on the last Thursday of every November. This explains why today’s Thanksgiving meal—with stuffed game and sugary fruit compote—feels so reminiscent of 19th-century menus.

Advertisement
Advertisement

In the Current issue

Archive »

Ask Westchester

Bathhouses, Birds  And Birdbrains

Bathhouses, Birds And Birdbrains

To see the connection, read on.

Archive »

Restaurant Reviews

Westchester’s Hottest Table

Westchester’s Hottest Table

Danny Meyer refugees set up shop in Armonk. Does Restaurant North measure up?

Archive »

Main Course

In Pursuit of the Perfect Loaf

In Pursuit of the Perfect Loaf

An ode to the shapes, crusts, crumbs, taste, and aroma of everything from buns to baguettes.

Archive »

High Note

She Checked It Out

She Checked It Out

Briarcliff author Marilyn Johnson gets the inside scoop on libraries and librarians.

Subscribe Now