Italian Combo

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros, Mamaroneck


When you step into this Mamaroneck Avenue Italian deli, you have to stop for a second and remember you’re in a place that only looks like it belongs on Arthur Avenue. Everything about it is spot on: the Italian grocery items, the prepared foods, and the intimidation factor when you’re called upon to place your order. When you hear, “Who’s next?!” you’d better step up, and you should order an Italian combo—on a wedge, so you can experience the bread’s chewy softness. The meat in combos differs from place to place, but at Cosmo & Alex, they’re giving us a variety of hams: domestic, mortadella, capicola, and prosciutto—all layered evenly, so as not to give too much of any single ham. All that is combined with a sharp and strong provolone, not too many veggies (lettuce and tomato) and a restrained use of oil and vinegar, so the cold cuts stand on their own. After all, that’s what you want to taste the most.

Edit ModuleShow Tags


Larchmont Tavern, Larchmont

The Julia Child

Got Thyme, New Rochelle

Pastrami And Corned Beef

Rye Ridge Delicatessen, Rye Brook & Stamford


Tarry Market, Port Chester


Iron Vine, Peekskill

The Super Wacky

Heavy Bear Deli, Yorktown Heights

Crispy Calamari Sandwich

251 Lex, Mount Kisco

Parm Stars

Eggplant, meatball, and chicken. These three are the best Parm sandwiches in the area.

Curried Chicken Salad Sandwich

Bedford Gourmet, Bedford

Chicken Souvlaki

MP Taverna, Irvington

Pig's Head Doughnut

The Cookery, Dobbs Ferry


Dinosaur BBQ, Stamford


Sandwiches always need a good side dish. Here are the best sides I had while writing this round-up.

Fresh Roasted Turkey

Melt Sandwich Company, White Plains


Most sandwiches are spread with a good sauce. These were the top three during this eating adventure.

Grilled Sausage And Broccoli Rabe

Amore Italian Kitchen, Armonk (lunch menu only)


Exit 4 Food Hall, Mount Kisco

Texas Sandwich

Café Mirage, Port Chester

Tammy Special (Chicken Cutlet)

Royal Scarlet Deli, White Plains

Italian Combo

Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros, Mamaroneck

140° Steak Sandwich

Village Social, Mount Kisco

Lobster Roll

Saltaire Oyster Bar, Port Chester


Porta Napoli, Harrison
Edit Module