Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa

Milton, NY

A view of the Hudson River from Buttermilk’s lawn

The portion of Route 9W leading to Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa does not make for an impressive drive—motor inns and tractor sales and wood-shed lots. But once you’re inside Buttermilk’s 70-acre compound, ugly memories fade fast: The setting is a celebration of water (a swan/duck pond, a waterfall, the Hudson River), animals (an aviary and a pen of rescued livestock), farm (the scatter of rustic buildings across verdant meadows), and earth (slate step paths wind through apple trees, an organic garden, and wine grape plantings). 

The 10-room, 1764 Main House is an 18th-century charmer filled with nooks and crannies, done up in white and taupe with wood floors and antique furnishings. There are also eight private guest houses/cottages around the property, including the two-bed stone-and-wood North Cottage perched on a cliff with river views. 

Mornings began with a creaky jaunt down the Main House’s narrow stairs for a country breakfast of farm-fresh omelets and homemade pastries, followed by unhurried stays on leather sofas as we contemplated the day ahead: Wander about the lush grounds or indulge in a treatment at the spa? (We did both, of course.) There are also tennis courts, an indoor pool, and cooking classes at the on-site farm-to-table Henry’s at the Farm.     

Explore: The area surrounding Buttermilk is perfect for unplugging and getting active outdoors. Just north on 9W, in Highland, New York, is the western entrance to The Walkway Over the Hudson, the longest elevated pedestrian bridge in the world, with grand views of the river valley. Also nearby is Minnewaska State Park and Mohonk Preserve for hiking. Shoppers can browse the funky retail outlets in New Paltz 20 minutes away, and foodies can visit one of the area wineries or pick-your-own fruit and veggie farms (DuBois Farms in Highland has a nice selection of “U-pick” fruits and veggies).  

Dine: Buttermilk Falls has a working 40-acre farm on-site, so its upmarket New American restaurant, Henry’s on the Farm, can claim genuine farm-to-table cred. Another legit farm-to-table dining destination is just a 20-minute drive away: the Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, New York. 

Insider's tip: Live music fans (especially jazz and blues lovers) will want to drive five miles south on 9W to Marlboro and visit The Falcon (www.liveatthefalcon.com), a live-performance venue and farm-to-table restaurant in a 19th-century button factory overlooking Marlboro Falls. 

Distance from White Plains: 1 hour, 15 minutes by car. Rates: standard rooms from $300/night

220 North Rd, Milton, NY
(845) 795-1310

Edit ModuleShow Tags

Black Point Inn

Prouts Neck, Maine

Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa

Milton, NY

Harbor View Hotel

Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts

Hershey Lodge

Hersheypark, Pennsylvania

Hidden Pond & The Tides Beach Club

Kennebunkport, Maine

Mirbeau Inn & Spa

Plymouth, Massachusetts

Montauk Blue Hotel

Montauk, New York

Sea Island

Sea Island, Georgia

The Mayflower Grace

Washington, Connecticut

The Sanctuary at Kiawah Island Golf Resort

Kiawah Island, South Carolina

The Vanderbilt Grace

Newport, Rhode Island

The White Barn Inn

Kennebunkport, Maine

Wequassett Resort and Golf Club

Cape Cod, Massachusetts
Edit Module